Jump to content
JWTalk - Jehovah's Witnesses Online Community

JW pressroom: Is military service a conscience matter now?


Recommended Posts

4 minutes ago, LeolaRootStew said:

Do you have a link to that?


Sure!

FAQ: Whole blood, leukocytes reduced (LrWB) at Canadian Blood Services | Professional Education
Backgrounder: Whole Blood | Canadian Blood Services

So sometimes it is called LrWB, but most of the time is it just called whole blood by non-JW and taken for granted that it is Lr.

"Jehovah’s Witnesses do not accept transfusions of whole blood. This stand is based on our understanding of passages in both the Old and New Testaments." (Link)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Medical Professional (Doctor, Nurse)

 

A medical professional performs their duties in accordance with established medical standards and principles of professional ethics. They are required to provide medical care to patients regardless of their nationality, citizenship, political or religious beliefs, social status, or affiliation with opposing sides in a conflict. Their professional responsibilities include medical examinations, diagnosis, treatment, patient care, and the provision of necessary medical assistance aimed at saving lives, maintaining and restoring health, and preserving vital bodily functions.

 

Of particular importance: Providing medical care to representatives of either side does not, in itself, imply support for either side, solidarity with it, or affiliation with its structures.

 

2. A Medical Professional Employed by a Ministry of Defence Medical Facility Without Military Status

 

International practice includes the employment of civilian medical professionals in medical facilities operated by the armed forces and Ministries of Defence. This practice also exists during peacetime. Such professionals include doctors, nurses, and other healthcare personnel. They may voluntarily choose to work in a military medical facility while retaining civilian employment status and without enlisting in the armed forces. Why is the Ministry of Defense recruiting civilian medical personnel to work in military medical facilities? There is an acute shortage of medical personnel, a need to ensure qualified medical care, and a need to fill shortages in military-registered specialties (surgeons, anesthesiologists, junior medical staff, etc.) that are lacking in the Armed Forces.

 

Two employment arrangements must be distinguished:

1. A civilian medical professional whose salary is paid from Ministry of Defence funds.

—Works in a military hospital or another medical facility that forms part of the Ministry of Defence organisational structure.
—The facility's activities are financed through the defence budget or other authorised sources.
—The employee's salary is paid from Ministry of Defence funds.
—The employee holds a civilian position under an employment contract.
—The employee is not enlisted in the armed forces and does not automatically acquire military status.

 

2. A civilian medical professional whose salary is paid from other funding sources.

—Works in a medical facility that organisationally forms part of the Ministry of Defence structure.
—The facility's activities or the employee's remuneration may be financed through other legally authorised sources that are not directly part of the Ministry of Defence budget.
—The employee retains civilian employment status.
—The employee is not enlisted in the armed forces and does not automatically acquire military status.

 

In both cases, the medical professional voluntarily chooses to work within a military organisation. However, the source of funding and the terms of employment may differ.

 

International Practice. The employment of civilian medical personnel within military medical organisations exists in Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States.

—Germany: The Bundeswehr provides civilian medical positions within its organisational structure.

https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/about-bundeswehr/ranks-and-careers/civilian-careers
—United Kingdom: The Ministry of Defence's Defence Medical Services includes both military personnel and civilian employees.

https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/defence-medical-services

—United States: The Department of Defense, through the Defense Health Agency, employs civilian doctors, nurses, and other healthcare professionals in military hospitals and clinics. https://mabu-civmed.taopowered.net/opportunities

 

Important Distinctions. When determining the nature of the employment, three separate factors must be considered:

—Organisational affiliation: Whether the medical facility forms part of the Ministry of Defence structure or operates as an independent civilian organisation.
—Funding: The sources used to finance the facility's operations and pay the medical professional's salary.
—Legal status: Whether the individual is employed as a civilian employee or serves as a member of the armed forces.

 

The key distinction: A civilian medical professional may voluntarily choose to work directly within a military organisational structure while retaining civilian employment status and not being a member of the armed forces. Their salary may be funded through the Ministry of Defence budget, another government ministry's budget (such as the Ministry of Health), or other legally authorised civilian funding sources. The source of salary funding does not, in itself, determine the employee's military or civilian status.

 

However, the employee's civilian status does not change the organisational affiliation of the facility in which they work. Conversely, employment in an independent civilian medical facility that provides services to military personnel under a contract does not, in itself, make that facility part of the military organisational structure. These circumstances must be considered separately, without confusing civilian medical employment, employment within a military organisation, and military service.


Edited by Dré
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Ivar said:


Sure!

FAQ: Whole blood, leukocytes reduced (LrWB) at Canadian Blood Services | Professional Education
Backgrounder: Whole Blood | Canadian Blood Services

So sometimes it is called LrWB, but most of the time is it just called whole blood by non-JW and taken for granted that it is Lr.

"Jehovah’s Witnesses do not accept transfusions of whole blood. This stand is based on our understanding of passages in both the Old and New Testaments." (Link)

 

I meant the Thailand brothers.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The fact of the matter is that Everything is a conscience matter.    Being one of Jehovah's Witnesses is completely voluntary.    Each one has to make the decision to dedicate their lives to Jehovah.   Each one must decide how deep that dedication goes.    The brothers are starting to weed out rules that are not in the Bible.  Each must apply the principles in the Bible based on their own understanding.  But beware,  there are still wrong answers.  Jehovah's standards do NOT change.   The burden of choice is ours.   Will we make the right decision based on accurate understanding of the scriptures, or will we "follow our hearts"

  • Like 1

“A kind man benefits himself, but the cruel person brings trouble on himself.”—PROVERBS 11:17.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anything an individual does is up to the individual's conscience.  Somone's conscience may allow them to be immoral, a thief, commit murder, or many other potential courses of action.

 

In order to please Jehovah, the individual's conscience must be in line with Jehovah's standards.

 

Jehovah's stardards regarding any of this world's (Caesar's world) military organization are VERY clear. He does not approve of any of this world's military.

 

So, are our individual consciences sufficiently in line with Jehovah's standards to the point that whatever the individual does brings joy to Jehovah's heart.

 

Serving an any of this world's military would NOT bring joy to Jehovah's heart. 

 

His stardards regarding participating in any military activity of this world are particularly plain in the scriptures.

 

When we compare the "choice" of military service (because of a public statement that military activity is a personal matter) to the "choice" an individual has regarding medical treatments that might include subsets of whole blood, we must remember the level of definition Jehovah gives rearding the prohibition of blood compared to the level of clarity we have in the Bible about Caesar's military. The Bible meerly says we are to "abstain from blood" without giving any further detail as to what is considered "blood."  If there is no specific guidance from the bible as to how many components of blood constitute "blood," then a christian must rely on his own conscience as to what Jehovah consideres to be "Blood."

 

However, wen it comes to ANY support of military of this world (i.e., Satan's world) Jehovah's standards are very clear. There is no basis for considering any participation in this world's military as "not meetng the bar" of definition to Jehovah in his stand on any support of Satan's world's military.

 

THESE ARE ALL MATTERS OF AN INDIVIDUAL'S CONSCIENCE.  

 

And many countries will allow an individual to assert several variations on what they are willing to do.

 

BUT WHEN ONE IS LOOKING AT AN OFFICIAL STATEMENT OF ANY ORGANIZATION - we are in a totally different environment.

 

When an organization makes an official statement that it is wrong to perform any minitary service, that organization is guilty of treason in many countries. An organization guilty of treason is some jurisdictions can suffer extreme difficulties, including (1) the organization being declared "illegal" having no "standing" in the eyes of the countyr, (2) as a result of not having "standing," all of the organization's proprty in that jurisdiction is confiscated, (3) all known members of the organization are subject to imprisonment (or even worse), and (4) many other negative things, including execution.

 

So, Jehovah's Organization, in it's well reasoned wisdom, presents to individuals the information as to what Jehovah's standards are, and then tells individuals it is their decision based on heir personal conscience as to what the individual should do to meet Jehovah's standards.

 

Thus, Jehovah's Organization has presented to each of us the information we need to make a personal decision.

 

By presenting the information in this manner, Jehovah's Organization avoied unnecessary problems with governments under Satan's control, and, at the same time, has given us the guidance we need to make a decision that will be approved by Jehovah.

 

As to the comment of some that we pay taxes, of which a considerable portion may go to military activities, Jesus' comment "Pay unto Cearsar what is Ceasar's" (paraphrase) gives clear guidance that his followers were not responsible for how Caesar uses the tax.

 

So, a Public Statement saying that Christians are free to make a decision based on thier on conscience in one area, does not mean that a properly trained conscience could interpret that to mean one can do what seems convenient at the moment.

 

When Jehovah only gives general guidance (as we have recently received clarification regarding blood), meaning one must exercise individual conscience in evluating choices in one situation, that does NOT mean that when Jehovah gives very clear guidance as to what is proper, we are free to do what is convenient at any moment.

 

A VERY CRUCIAL point was made in an earlier post in this thread that there is a SIGNIFICANT difference between alternative CiVILIAN service and any variaton of MILITARY service. As for serving as a "medic" treating military wounded, to have the position as "medic" that individual is by definition a part of the military.

 

What position in any military in Satan's world would meet with Jehovah's approval?

 

Thanks,

 

Jim 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dear Brother Ivar,

You raise some very important questions that require very careful consideration and research, because we all want to do what is right and, most importantly, to make sure that our conduct is in harmony with Jehovah’s laws and the principles set out in the Bible as guidance for all of us who desire to serve Jehovah.

 

To understand the modern concepts of “armed forces” and “civilian population,” it is important to consider the historical development of international law and how the legal meaning of the terms combatants and non-combatants has evolved over time.

 

1. Historical distinction within the armed forces

 

As early as 1874, the Project of an International Declaration Concerning the Laws and Customs of War, Brussels, August 27, 1874, Art. 11, provided for a distinction between combatants and non-combatants within the armed forces: “On military authority over hostile territory: The armed forces of the belligerent parties may consist of combatants and non-combatants. In case of capture by the enemy, both shall enjoy the rights of prisoners of war.”

https://hrlibrary.umn.edu/instree/1874a.htm

 

This provision was subsequently incorporated into Article 3 of the Hague Regulations of 1899 https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hague02.asp and retained in Article 3 of the Hague Regulations of 1907 https://hrlibrary.law.umn.edu/instree/1907c.htm

 

Thus, historically, non-combatant did not mean a civilian. A non-combatant member of the armed forces and a civilian were two different legal categories.

 

2. Change in the legal approach in 1977

 

A significant change took place with the adoption of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions on June 8, 1977. 

https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/ihl-treaties/api-1977/article-43

 

Article 43(1) defines the armed forces as organized armed forces, groups and units under a command responsible to a Party to the conflict:

1. The armed forces of a Party to a conflict consist of all organized armed forces, groups and units which are under a command responsible to that Party for the conduct of its subordinates, even if that Party is represented by a government or an authority not recognized by an adverse Party. Such armed forces shall be subject to an internal disciplinary system which, ' inter alia ', shall enforce compliance with the rules of international law applicable in armed conflict.

 

Article 43(2) provides:

2. Members of the armed forces of a Party to a conflict (other than medical personnel and chaplains covered by Article 33 of the Third Convention) are combatants, that is to say, they have the right to participate directly in hostilities.

 

Consequently, membership in the armed forces became the principal legal criterion: a member of the armed forces is generally considered a combatant, regardless of whether that person performs combat or support duties directly. Medical personnel and chaplains are exceptions and have a special status. It is therefore more accurate to say that in 1977 the former legal distinction between combatants and non-combatants within the armed forces was eliminated, rather than that non-combatant or auxiliary military service itself was abolished.

 

3. Why was this change made?

 

The reason was primarily the development of the principle of distinction between combatants and the civilian population. Additional Protocol I established this fundamental principle in Article 48, requiring the parties to a conflict at all times to distinguish between the civilian population and combatants, as well as between civilian objects and military objectives. The ICRC identifies this principle as one of the foundations of the system of civilian protection under modern international humanitarian law:

“In order to ensure respect for and protection of the civilian population and civilian objects, the Parties to the conflict shall at all times distinguish between the civilian population and combatants and between civilian objects and military objectives and accordingly shall direct their operations only against military objectives.”

https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/ihl-treaties/api-1977/article-48?activeTab=

 

In other words, international law gradually moved away from the former question: “Is this particular member of the armed forces a combatant or a non-combatant?” and focused on the more fundamental distinction: “Is this person a member of the armed forces (a combatant), or a civilian?”

 

International law did not abolish non-combatant military duties as such. Rather, it changed the legal classification of members of the armed forces: the former category of non-combatants within the armed forces was largely replaced by the modern approach under which members of the armed forces are generally considered combatants. The principal legal distinction is now between the armed forces (combatants) and the civilian population.

 

As of 2026, the fundamental approach of international humanitarian law established by Additional Protocol I of 1977 has not changed.

 

According to Article 43(2) of the Protocol, members of the armed forces are generally considered combatants, regardless of whether they perform direct combat duties or non-combatant or auxiliary military duties, such as supply, transportation, communications or technical maintenance. The exceptions are military medical personnel and military chaplains. They may also be members of the armed forces; however, they have a special legal status, are not classified as combatants and enjoy special protection under international humanitarian law. https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/ihl-treaties/api-1977/article-43

 

Civilians constitute a separate legal category. They do not become members of the armed forces merely because they accompany military forces or provide support to them. https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/ihl-treaties/api-1977/article-48

 

Therefore, it is important to distinguish between the nature of a person's duties and their legal status. Performing non-combatant or auxiliary military duties does not, in itself, mean that a member of the armed forces is a civilian or a non-combatant. This distinction is fundamental to the modern approach of international humanitarian law. 

 

Who are prisoners of war?
Combatants can be members of the regular armed forces, as well as militia, volunteers or other such groups if they belong to a party to the conflict and fulfil certain conditions. A small number of non-combatants, such as medics, journalists, supply contractors, and civilian crew members, are also entitled to prisoner-of-war status when they are affiliated with or have special permission to accompany the armed forces. There is also a possibility for civilians who spontaneously take up arms in a 'levée en masse' to be prisoners of war. POW status is regulated by the Third Geneva Convention and Additional Protocol I.

https://www.icrc.org/en/document/FAQ-rules-of-war-ihl?language=en

 

Do civilians picking up arms lose their protection against direct attack under IHL?
International humanitarian law (IHL) defines civilians as anyone who is neither a member of State armed forces, nor a member of an organized armed group with a continuous combat function, nor a participant in a levée en masse. To protect civilians, combatants – and anyone directly participating in hostilities – must distinguish themselves from civilians in all military operations by wearing identifiable insignia and carrying arms openly.

https://www.icrc.org/en/document/FAQ-rules-of-war-ihl?language=en

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation with your brothers and sisters!


You can post now, and then we will take you to the membership application. If you are already a member, sign in now to post with your existing account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

About JWTalk.net - Jehovah's Witnesses Online Community

Since 2006, JWTalk has proved to be a well-moderated online community for real Jehovah's Witnesses on the web. However, our community is not an official website of Jehovah's Witnesses. It is not endorsed, sponsored, or maintained by any legal entity used by Jehovah's Witnesses. We are a pro-JW community maintained by brothers and sisters around the world. We expect all community members to be active publishers in their congregations, therefore, please do not apply for membership if you are not currently one of Jehovah's Witnesses.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

JWTalk 23.8.11 (changelog)