1. Medical Professional (Doctor, Nurse)
A medical professional performs their duties in accordance with established medical standards and principles of professional ethics. They are required to provide medical care to patients regardless of their nationality, citizenship, political or religious beliefs, social status, or affiliation with opposing sides in a conflict. Their professional responsibilities include medical examinations, diagnosis, treatment, patient care, and the provision of necessary medical assistance aimed at saving lives, maintaining and restoring health, and preserving vital bodily functions.
Of particular importance: Providing medical care to representatives of either side does not, in itself, imply support for either side, solidarity with it, or affiliation with its structures.
2. A Medical Professional Employed by a Ministry of Defence Medical Facility Without Military Status
International practice includes the employment of civilian medical professionals in medical facilities operated by the armed forces and Ministries of Defence. This practice also exists during peacetime. Such professionals include doctors, nurses, and other healthcare personnel. They may voluntarily choose to work in a military medical facility while retaining civilian employment status and without enlisting in the armed forces. Why is the Ministry of Defense recruiting civilian medical personnel to work in military medical facilities? There is an acute shortage of medical personnel, a need to ensure qualified medical care, and a need to fill shortages in military-registered specialties (surgeons, anesthesiologists, junior medical staff, etc.) that are lacking in the Armed Forces.
Two employment arrangements must be distinguished:
1. A civilian medical professional whose salary is paid from Ministry of Defence funds.
—Works in a military hospital or another medical facility that forms part of the Ministry of Defence organisational structure.
—The facility's activities are financed through the defence budget or other authorised sources.
—The employee's salary is paid from Ministry of Defence funds.
—The employee holds a civilian position under an employment contract.
—The employee is not enlisted in the armed forces and does not automatically acquire military status.
2. A civilian medical professional whose salary is paid from other funding sources.
—Works in a medical facility that organisationally forms part of the Ministry of Defence structure.
—The facility's activities or the employee's remuneration may be financed through other legally authorised sources that are not directly part of the Ministry of Defence budget.
—The employee retains civilian employment status.
—The employee is not enlisted in the armed forces and does not automatically acquire military status.
In both cases, the medical professional voluntarily chooses to work within a military organisation. However, the source of funding and the terms of employment may differ.
International Practice. The employment of civilian medical personnel within military medical organisations exists in Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States.
—Germany: The Bundeswehr provides civilian medical positions within its organisational structure.
https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/about-bundeswehr/ranks-and-careers/civilian-careers
—United Kingdom: The Ministry of Defence's Defence Medical Services includes both military personnel and civilian employees.
https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/defence-medical-services
—United States: The Department of Defense, through the Defense Health Agency, employs civilian doctors, nurses, and other healthcare professionals in military hospitals and clinics. https://mabu-civmed.taopowered.net/opportunities
Important Distinctions. When determining the nature of the employment, three separate factors must be considered:
—Organisational affiliation: Whether the medical facility forms part of the Ministry of Defence structure or operates as an independent civilian organisation.
—Funding: The sources used to finance the facility's operations and pay the medical professional's salary.
—Legal status: Whether the individual is employed as a civilian employee or serves as a member of the armed forces.
The key distinction: A civilian medical professional may voluntarily choose to work directly within a military organisational structure while retaining civilian employment status and not being a member of the armed forces. Their salary may be funded through the Ministry of Defence budget, another government ministry's budget (such as the Ministry of Health), or other legally authorised civilian funding sources. The source of salary funding does not, in itself, determine the employee's military or civilian status.
However, the employee's civilian status does not change the organisational affiliation of the facility in which they work. Conversely, employment in an independent civilian medical facility that provides services to military personnel under a contract does not, in itself, make that facility part of the military organisational structure. These circumstances must be considered separately, without confusing civilian medical employment, employment within a military organisation, and military service.